When former Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin first pushed for a “bell-to-bell” cellphone ban in Virginia’s public schools, there was already strong evidence that cellphones harmed adolescents. Whether students would learn more if schools banned phones was an open question. Youngkin and other elected officials had the good sense to act on the evidence they had. Now, a new national study gives schools across the country good reason to follow their example.
Americans tend to date the decline in student achievement to the spring of 2020, when, amid an overreaction to COVID-19, schools closed and sent children home to learn on laptops. But the decline really started years before the pandemic.
Around 2013, as smartphones became common, students began falling behind by about two or three weeks of learning per year. A few weeks might be easy to miss on any one report card. But over a decade, the losses added up. By 2024, the average eighth grader was nearly a full grade level behind the average eighth grader in 2013.
Aware of research linking heavy cellphone and social media use to anxiety and depression among adolescents, Youngkin sensed that banning phones from schools could improve academic achievement, too. In July 2024, he directed Virginia’s Department of Education to develop a statewide policy. The guidance it issued called on schools to prohibit students from carrying their phones from the first bell to the last, including during lunch and breaks between classes. His administration recommended locked pouches as a way for schools to enforce this rule.
Democrats fought Youngkin’s “bell-to-bell” ban, introducing legislation that would have limited phone bans to class time and allowed students to get back to social media surfing between classes. Youngkin’s bell-to-bell approach ultimately prevailed. Since July of this year, every Virginia public school has been required to keep students off their phones from the first bell to the last.
Not every state or school district has adopted Virginia’s policy, and the uneven spread of cellphone bans has given researchers at Harvard and Dartmouth an opportunity to study what works best. Using five years of test results from 3.3 million students at 4,600 schools, they examined how much students learned before and after their schools adopted “bell-to-bell” bans enforced with lockable pouches. They compared those results with the progress of students in similar schools without that policy. The results were clear: Students whose phones were locked away gained the equivalent of one to two extra weeks of learning in math and reading each year.
YOUNGKIN’S BRILLIANT PHONE-FREE SCHOOL MODEL
Why does it matter where a student keeps his phone if he already knows he is supposed to leave it alone during class? Ask a teacher how long it takes a teenager to check a text while she turns to write on the board. Compared with staff at schools with no formal ban, staff at schools that banned phones during lessons reported that the share of students using phones for personal reasons in class was 11 percentage points lower. That difference rose to 18 points for ordinary bell-to-bell bans and 28 points for schools using locked pouches. A phone locked away can wait until dismissal. A phone in a pocket is a constant, tempting distraction.
Some parents will object that they need to reach their children during the school day. If a ride home falls through or a family emergency arises, the school office can get a message to a student, just as it did for generations. Governors, mayors, and school board members should stand firm when those complaints come and require students to lock up their phones from the first bell to the last. Few changes a school can make offer children the chance to gain an extra week or two of learning without adding a single day to the calendar.
