Dave McCormick calls Holocaust museum decolonization speech ‘garbage’

.

Sen. Dave McCormick (R-PA) on Wednesday unleashed on a Canadian scholar over a lecture at Pennsylvania State University discussing the decolonization of Holocaust museums, calling the lecture “garbage.”

Erica Lehrer, a sociocultural anthropologist and museum curator at Concordia University in Montreal, gave a 90-minute lecture Tuesday night at Penn State examining the question, “Do we need to decolonize Holocaust museums?” In the buildup to the event, Lehrer faced significant backlash from Jewish organizations that deemed her lecture antisemitic.

“This lecture is fake, garbage ‘scholarship,’” McCormick said in a X post. “As a soldier, I and so many others fought for our freedoms, including freedom of speech. Just as important as academic freedom are academic rigor and the quality of our education system.”

“As I told my good friend, the president of Penn State, this morning, the ideas highlighted in this lecture are not only deeply offensive rot, but they are also nonsensical gibberish unworthy of a great university,” he added.

Jeff Miller, CEO of lobbying firm Miller Strategies and chairman of the Holocaust Memorial Museum Council, also criticized the lecture after it was posted by watchdog StopAntisemitism.

“We cannot combat the rising tide of antisemitism while allowing the historical truth of the Holocaust to be diminished or manipulated,” Miller said. “Never Again must mean something.”

After receiving backlash for the lecture’s topic, Lehrer told the Jerusalem Post that she was giving the lecture as “a person whose own mother’s family heirlooms were donated to a Holocaust museum.”

“Most of the questions I am exploring relate to how Holocaust museums may learn from Indigenous innovations regarding more flexible ways to care for objects that keeps them connected to families and communities rather than only under glass, as evidence of crimes,” she said of her discussion.

Lehrer said the lecture also discussed how different sects of Holocaust victims, such as Roma people, have been represented in “ways that are stereotypical and don’t express their full humanity.” She is also a fellow at the Holocaust Memorial Museum, and she noted that other scholars have raised similar questions about content at museums.

After Lehrer’s explanation, Carly Pildis, the director of advocacy for One Mitzvah A Day A Project of the Jewish Federations of North America, came in support. Pildis argued stones may have been cast too soon.

“The lecture was organized by the Jewish studies department,” Pildis said. “I am no museum studies expert, but care/ownership of historical artifacts is a common debate.”

RAND PAUL BLASTS VANCE, ICE, AND ‘TONE-DEAF’ GOP AS HE EYES HIS 2028 LANE

According to Tommaso M. Milani, director of the Jewish Studies Program at Penn State, “decolonization” refers to a discussion on how museums curate collections, particularly which groups are represented and how “historical injustices related to the acquisition and presentation of their collections” can be addressed.

A spokesperson for Penn State issued an apology on behalf of the university, saying leaders “understand the concerns regarding the external speaker’s use of the word ‘decolonization’ in the event’s title, and we recognize how hurtful it was to many in our community.” The university noted that the presence of a speaker “in no way constitutes an endorsement” of the person’s viewpoints.

Related Content