When Irish author Sally Rooney promised to send her book royalties to the designated terrorist group Palestine Action, her British publisher, Faber, announced it could no longer sell her books in the United Kingdom.
Rooney was depicted as a victim of censorship and capitalist greed by the progressive Left. Dozens of high-profile writers and actors publicly came to her defense. No doubt, her works will soon be featured on those ludicrous “banned book” displays right next to books by other bestselling authors whose books are widely available.
Around the same time, a court in a Paris suburb was putting the novelist Michel Houellebecq under an official criminal investigation for “complicity in incitement to discrimination, hatred or violence” against Muslims. The author faces the possibility of a year in prison and a $50,000 fine.
As of this writing, not one high-profile writer or actor has come to his defense.
The investigation stems from three comments during a 2022 conversation with the French philosopher Michel Onfray:
First, the author argued that the notion that France’s population was being demographically replaced by immigrants from Muslim-majority countries is “not a theory, it’s a fact.”
Second, Houellebecq said the French people didn’t want Muslims to assimilate but rather to “stop stealing from and attacking them” or else “leave.”
Third, he predicted that if areas of France came under Islamist control, natives would begin carrying out counterattacks, describing them as “Bataclans in reverse,” a reference to the 2015 terrorist attack by three French Islamists that left 130 people dead.
Houellebecq, who thrives on incendiary rhetoric, would later call these remarks “clumsy.”
Viewed from the small-l liberal perspective, the indictment makes no sense. Make what you will of his positions. There’s no incitement to violence. These are merely observations. But, of course, the French do not treat free expression as a neutral right.
This is not the first time Houellebecq has been prosecuted for inciting “racial hatred.” In 2001, he was indicted on charges of an offhand remark made during an interview in which he called Islam “the most stupid religion” and described the Koran as “appalling.” If the novelist had made comparable remarks about the Christian or Jewish Bible, no one in the literary world, much less the authorities, would have cared. Indeed, Houellebecq would likely have won a Nobel Prize by now.
Perhaps that incident prompted Houellebecq to write his 2015 satirical novel Submission, released the same day that French-born Algerian brothers attacked Charlie Hebdo in Paris. The book imagines France as a dystopian nation in which left-wing parties join forces with Islamists to stop a far-right electoral victory. In the aftermath, the French progressively begin appeasing Muslim concerns until the country effectively becomes a theocratic state.
It shouldn’t escape our attention that the criminal complaint against the author of the satirical novel Submission was brought by a leftist NGO and the Union of Mosques of France, which represents religious institutions that are regularly exposed as preaching jihadist hate.
The alliance between leftists and Islamists is thriving across the West. We see it every time a leftist French rioter is draped in a keffiyeh.
But in France, one is free to participate in massive marches supporting Hamas and other murderous Islamic groups without worrying about indictments for hate speech. But if a person points out why there’s been an explosion of anti-Christian crimes or why armed French police need to guard Jewish neighborhoods and establishments, they may end up in court.
Rooney will never be prosecuted for her unhinged hatred of the Jewish state, nor will she ever have to go into hiding like Houellebecq or the French philosopher Robert Redeker, who pointed out the Koran was “a book of incredible violence,” or Theo van Gogh or Ayaan Hirsi Ali or Kurt Westergaard or Salman Rushdie.
The infamous Iranian fatwa against Rushdie, author of The Satanic Verses, was meant to suppress free expression in the liberal Western world through intimidation. There were firebombings and assassinations. Only a few years ago, an American Islamist stabbed Rushdie in the neck as he was being introduced for an event at the Chautauqua Institution in New York.
But the real tragedy is the surrender of the liberal Westerner.
DON’T WORRY DEMOCRATS WILL BLOW IT
As author Kenan Malik noted, the legacy of the Rushdie fatwa was that Western Europe had “internalized” censorship. “Rushdie’s critics lost the battle — The Satanic Verses continues to be published,” he wrote. “But they won the war. The argument at the heart of the anti-Rushdie case — that it is morally unacceptable to cause offence to other cultures — is now widely accepted.”
Only one culture believes it should be immune from criticism or satire. And Houellebecq’s indictment is merely more evidence that his satire is crashing into reality.
