Ron Johnson’s plan to bankrupt America

.

When Sen. Ron Johnson (R-WI) first campaigned for the Senate in 2010, he told voters, “I believe Congress is squandering America’s future with reckless amounts of spending and debt.” Now, 16 years later, he has introduced a bill that would add $5 trillion in spending, add $8 trillion in debt, and risk pricing more young people out of their first home. It may be the worst piece of legislation filed this decade.

Johnson is trying to address a real and difficult issue: the impending exhaustion of the Social Security Trust Fund. Social Security was created in 1935 but did not begin collecting payroll taxes until 1937 and did not begin paying benefits until 1940, allowing reserves to accumulate. In 1939, Congress created the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance Trust Fund to manage excess revenues.

As originally passed, Social Security would have been self-sufficient indefinitely, but starting with President Harry Truman in 1950, presidents from both parties appealed to elderly voters by promising to boost their Social Security checks. They kept their promises, resulting in the fiscal health of the trust fund declining to the brink of bankruptcy in the mid-1970s.

In 1977, Congress passed bipartisan legislation that cut benefits and raised payroll taxes to make the system solvent again. But those patches only lasted five years before the trust fund was exhausted again. In 1983, Congress again passed bipartisan legislation raising taxes and cutting benefits that should have made the system solvent indefinitely. Unfortunately, the formula Congress relied on assumed American families would continue having children, who would eventually become workers, at the same rate as in 1983. That hasn’t happened. The national fertility rate has fallen 20% since then and is now below replacement level. This means there are not enough workers to support the retirees in the system.

The trust fund still managed to build up reserves after the 1983 reforms, but as fertility declined, benefit payments began to outpace tax revenue. By 2010, Social Security’s annual costs exceeded its income from sources other than interest. The Social Security trustees now project that reserves will run out in the fourth quarter of 2032.

At that point, by law, the retirement trust fund could no longer pay everyone in full and on time. Its remaining revenue would cover only 78% of scheduled retirement and survivor benefits. Beneficiaries would still be entitled to their full benefits, but the law does not specify whether they would receive reduced checks on time or full checks late.

This would be a painful event and would force Congress to make the system solvent again. In the past, that has meant bipartisan deals that cut spending and raised taxes. Congress should pursue a similar outcome today, preferably by cutting benefits. The sooner, the better.

Unfortunately, the legislation Johnson introduced this week would short-circuit such an adjustment. His Stop Scaring Seniors Act would require the Treasury to cover monthly shortfalls in the retirement trust fund out of the general fund. This would put the checks on the nation’s credit card and let the Treasury keep charging even after Washington hits its credit limit.

The tab Johnson wants to run up is big. Based on the Social Security trustees’ projections, the Treasury would have to borrow roughly $5 trillion to cover the shortfalls from 2032 through 2041. At today’s borrowing costs, interest would bring the tab to roughly $6.5 trillion. If Treasury borrowing costs averaged 10%, the tab would reach $8 trillion.

This tsunami of debt would hit the young hardest. It would load them with future debt payments and would make it immediately more expensive for them to buy homes and start families. It is just such a skewing of economic benefits toward seniors and away from young people that is turning so many toward socialism.

If Washington has to offer investors 10% to lend it money, what will a young couple have to pay on a mortgage? A rise in mortgage rates from 5% to 10% would raise the monthly payment on a $400,000, 30-year loan from about $2,150 to $3,510. That’s $16,300 less a year for food, transportation, healthcare, and everything else. For a manufacturer carrying a $1 million loan balance for a year, the rate increase would mean an extra $50,000 in interest. That could be enough to put off buying a new machine and hiring someone to run it.

DEMOCRATS AREN’T SERIOUS ABOUT GUN CRIME

Social Security depends on young adults finding good jobs and raising the next generation of workers to pay into the system. By avoiding the tough spending and tax decisions necessary to make the system solvent and instead putting everything on the nation’s credit card, Johnson is not only failing to make tough but necessary choices but also pointing America toward spiraling debt and decline.

The legal limit on what Social Security can pay once its reserves run out is the only hope conservatives have of producing an outcome that shrinks the size of government and restores fiscal health. By removing that spending constraint and authorizing the Treasury to load up the nation’s credit card, Johnson is asking conservatives to surrender their best chance to rein in the spending he went to Washington to stop.

Related Content