Think the Mamdani joke was offensive? Stop ignoring child marriage in Gaza

.

A former Goldman Sachs analyst, Arynne Wexler, has been making quite a splash with her shock-jock comedy routines that often make pointed references to Muslim practices, including child marriage and bought wives. She joked about how New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and his wife keep their marriage fresh: “Their foreplay consists of listening to old speeches by Ayatollah Khomeini. That really gets them in the mood.”

His wife, Rama Duwaji, is a successful illustrator for Vogue and the New Yorker. They met in 2021 on the dating app Hinge. Wexler described their meeting as follows: “I assumed he had bought her. When she was 12. Folks, relax, I’m just kidding, I’m just kidding. She was 13. No, actually, they met on J-Date. But the J stands for jihad.”

Not surprisingly, Wexler has been decried as racist and Islamophobic. However inappropriate her routines — if performed in the United Kingdom, she would be jailed — they raise uncomfortable aspects of family practices that are not uncommon in Muslim communities worldwide. These practices go well beyond the usual criticisms of Sharia law: restrictions on how they dress and the education they seek. And some of them have profound effects today on young Gazan women.

A long-standing concern has been the practice of female genital mutilation, the surgical removal of the clitoris and/or the labia. According to a 2024 UNICEF update, 230 million women worldwide have been subject to this procedure. The majority are in African countries, but 60 million Asians and 6 million Middle Eastern women experienced FGM, too. An estimated 98% of Somali women have experienced FGM, and at 87%, Egypt is not far behind. Despite long-standing criticisms, there are still 4 million procedures performed each year.

Just as widespread are consanguineous marriages, or marriages between first and second cousins. This year, consanguineous marriages were 50% or more in Pakistan and Afghanistan, and over 25% in every Muslim Middle East country. And as Muslims migrated to Europe, rates declined but are still high. For example, a British study found a sharp decline in consanguinity in the Pakistani community — from 60% to 40% overall. Rather than banning consanguineous marriages, the Labor Party believes that required genetic counseling is the direction to pursue.

Child marriage within Muslim communities is also a concern. In Afghanistan and Yemen, half of all marriages are to girls younger than 15 years old. Muslim states in northern Nigeria have similar rates. The consequences have been devastating. Nigeria has the highest maternal mortality rate in Africa and one of the world’s highest rates of fistula, a condition that can occur when the pressure of childbirth tears a hole between the vagina and the bladder or rectum. Many women are left incontinent for life.

In the Middle East, national rates are much lower. For example, in Egypt, the national rate was 3.9% in 2000 but down to 2.2% by 2014, similar to rates in Gaza and the West Bank. While these national rates can be low, as in northern Nigeria, rural rates are often much higher. In 2006, 13% of Syrian girls married before age 18 and 3% married before age 15. But child marriage rates were twice as high in rural areas.

Child marriage is of deep concern in Gaza today, as families have been disrupted, if not destroyed, by the war. In particular, the male combat losses have increased the share of female-headed households from 1 in 9 before the war to 1 in 4 today. This has dramatically increased polygamy, as many widows choose to become second or third wives to gain financial security.

More troubling, researchers spoke to women who said young girls were married off to rapists, traded for food, or given up by guardians who did not want to take care of them. Even well-meaning intentions are no guarantee of positive outcomes.

As reported by the Associated Press, Majda, a woman in Gaza destitute and paralyzed by grief, married her daughters off at the ages of 13 and 14 to two brothers in their 20s. “I thought I was protecting them,” she said.

The two girls said their husbands raped them and that their in-laws beat them. Majda’s elder daughter fled, carrying her baby 9 miles to her mother’s tent, according to the outlet. The younger sister had two miscarriages and fled back to her mother during her third pregnancy.

“We are witnessing the dismantling of a generation’s future,” U.N. Population Fund representative Nestor Owomuhangi said.

Girls in Gaza are not choosing marriage — they are being driven into it by hunger, fear, and displacement. A 15-year-old girl should be in a classroom, not facing the life-threatening risks of pregnancy in a world where healthcare has all but collapsed. Child marriage is not protection — it is a form of gender-based violence that robs girls of their childhood, their health, and their future.

WHY THE LEFT’S PUSH FOR SUPREME COURT REFORM MISSES THE MARK

This evidence raises a number of issues. For the United States, there are large numbers of children of immigrants, given the prevalence of FGM in their parents’ country of origin, most notably Somalia, who are at risk of genital mutilation. A government community health study found that among those Somali women who migrated when less than 13 years old, 40% experienced FGM, but it was only 7% among those born here. In Sweden, Somali community members interviewed believed 12% of Somali children experience FGM. Thus, FGM is dramatically lower among children born to Somali immigrants because U.S. and Western European countries strongly enforce laws prohibiting the practice.

More concerning is the dynamic going on in Gaza. The dramatic loss of men and the dire economic circumstances have led to devastating effects on women because Muslim norms allow child marriage and polygamy. Israel’s critics will say that this is just an outcome of the country’s genocidal actions. However, the gender imbalance has resulted from the IDF’s effective targeting of male combatants. More importantly, unless Hamas is reined in so that rebuilding can begin, these abuses will continue.

Robert Cherry is an American Enterprise Institute affiliate and author of Arab Citizens of Israel: How Far Have They Come? (Wicked Son Press, 2026).

Related Content