Take air-traffic control out of Washington’s shutdown fights

.

Friday the 13th lived up to its name. Friday’s four-hour nationwide groundstop disrupted at least 18,000 flights throughout the weekend, with delays still continuing. It wreaked havoc on passengers’ schedules and should be a wake-up call for American aviation.

The Federal Aviation Administration puts safety first and deserves credit for halting flights when communications problems arose Friday afternoon. The culprit was allegedly malfunctions in a router that occurred while replacing old copper wire with fiber-optic cable. The cause is still under investigation.

The Air Traffic Organization, the FAA’s operational arm, needs more resources. It lags far behind its counterparts in Australia, Canada, and Western Europe in deploying 21st-century technology.

Since the Federal Aviation Agency, the FAA’s precursor, was formed in 1958, air-traffic control technology, aircraft avionics, and engine reliability have advanced considerably. Yet despite many well-intentioned attempts, the FAA’s funding structure has barely changed in more than five decades. The agency, with a $22 billion budget, remains poorly financed, and the management reforms enacted in the late 1990s remain largely unused.

The ATO depends on Congress for funding, and communications equipment needs to be updated. If the ATO were private, as in Canada, or a public-private partnership, as in some Western European countries, revenues would rise as more people flew, just as more bakeries open when more people want bread. Additional revenues can fund better communications equipment.

Under such a system, user fees would go directly to the ATO, which would provide the services. There could be multiple air-traffic control providers, as long as they meet government performance standards. Some express safety concerns with air traffic services contracted out to private operators, but no one worries about flying to Toronto, Berlin, or London because of partly privately provided air-traffic control.

The shortcomings of U.S. air-traffic control have been documented for decades by the Government Accountability Office and the Department of Transportation’s Inspector General. The latest GAO report, released in September 2026, found major problems with communications.

The report presciently stated, “Copper cables are from the 1960s. Technology is no longer supported by the communications providers. Incidents stemming from unsupported technology have the most direct impact on the ATC environment due to the potential for operational disruptions.”

The best solution is to transform the ATO into a public-private partnership. If Congress refuses to do that, it must be modernized. In 2025, Congress provided $12.5 billion toward Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy’s estimated $31.5 billion cost of modernizing air-traffic control. Over the weekend, Duffy asked Congress for $50 billion, up from the $30 billion the president had requested, saying, “I want Congress to give us emergency funding. This is bipartisan. This is American.”

This investment is overdue. The FAA’s dependence on annual appropriations stifles efficiency and innovation. The FAA should focus on rapidly testing, evaluating, and certifying private-sector innovations rather than slowing progress.

In the long term, to regain America’s global leadership in aviation and to allow funds to flow into the ATO, the United States could:

Separate the FAA from DOT, or, at a minimum, separate the ATO from the FAA.

Reform the FAA’s funding system so the U.S. aviation system is not held prisoner to annual appropriations or used as a political football to solve non-aviation problems.

Shift from aviation user taxes to fees for air traffic services, paid directly to the ATO.

Allow the ATO to issue long-term revenue bonds for major projects.

WHAT WENT WRONG, AND HOW REPUBLICANS CAN BEGIN TO EARN BACK TRUST

Americans shrug when Congress shuts down the government, as happens periodically, but they notice when their flights are canceled. Friday’s groundstop showed what happens when the nation’s air-traffic system depends on annual appropriations and is used as a bargaining chip in unrelated political fights.

Canada and several Western European countries have shown a better way: an air-traffic provider funded by the people who use it, not by the whims of the legislature. Congress should fund the modernization Secretary Duffy has begun. It should also give the ATO the financial independence to carry it out. The next shutdown will come, and travelers should not have to pay for it again.

Diana Furchtgott-Roth, former deputy assistant secretary for Research and Technology at the U.S. Department of Transportation, is a Distinguished Fellow at the Energy Policy Research Foundation.

Related Content