The defense bill provision that would leave our warfighters less safe

.

House and Senate Armed Services leaders meet twice this week to finish the National Defense Authorization Act before Democrats take control of Congress in January. The Senate version contains a Democrat section that would leave our warfighters less safe.

Section 815, a little-discussed provision forbidding stock buybacks and dividends by defense contractors, would weaken the Department of War and give political appointees a tool to control how American companies govern themselves. Republicans still have time to strip it from the final bill.

During my years on the Senate banking committee, I fought to keep politicians and bureaucrats out of decisions that belong to boards and shareholders. Determining when, how, and in what amounts to return money to a business’s owners is a fundamental and apolitical responsibility of a board of directors.

This all started with good intentions. Pay should follow performance, a simple principle that has fueled the American economy for generations. Earlier this year, President Donald Trump signed Executive Order 14372, targeting underperforming defense contractors who have failed to deliver promised weapons on time. Under the order, those contractors may not pay dividends or repurchase shares until they deliver quality products on time and on budget.

But in Washington, nothing stays narrow for long. Give politicians an inch, and they’ll take a mile. Section 815 would require contractors to agree in writing not to repurchase shares or pay dividends — even ordinary dividends — for the duration of any contract awarded. It applies to any company that wins a defense contract, regardless of the size of the company or the contract. And the secretary of war can waive the restriction for any contractor he chooses.

Progressives have wanted this power for years. Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) routinely characterizes stock buybacks as market manipulation designed to inflate executive pay. In January, she is expected to take over the Senate banking committee, which writes the securities laws that govern buybacks. Days after the election, she told CBS’s Face the Nation that she has a bill ready to cap credit card interest rates at 10%. “I got the bill. I’m ready to go,” she said. Section 815 would hand her a federal buyback restriction that she could extend to the rest of the economy.

But the waiver provision bestowed upon the secretary of war should worry Republicans just as much. Because the secretary of war can grant waivers, a future Democratic administration could demand that contractors adopt its agenda on, say, labor issues; diversity, equity, and inclusion; environmental, social, and governance standards; or anything else. Political appointees would effectively control the boards of the very companies we count on to keep America safe.

Faced with a choice between a Pentagon contract and the freedom to run their own company and return capital to their owners, many companies will simply walk away. Smaller, more innovative firms will drop out of Pentagon supply chains, and so could the energy, telecom and tech companies that sell the Pentagon its fuel, phones and software but earn most of their revenue elsewhere. Fewer bidders mean less competition. Less competition means higher costs for taxpayers, slower innovation and weaker capabilities for our military.

Section 815 would also hurt the people who actually own these companies. When a company buys back its own shares or pays dividends, the cash doesn’t vanish. It goes to shareholders, including the pension funds and 401(k)s of current and future retirees, who typically reinvest it, often in younger, faster-growing companies.

OPINION — MAO’S ‘MAGIC WEAPON’: HEGSETH JUST EXPOSED 80 REBRANDED CHINESE CELLS ON CAMPUS

The Pentagon’s alternative for dealing with underperforming contractors is obvious. If a contractor fails to deliver, hold it accountable through the contract: withhold payment, enforce penalties, set clear performance benchmarks, and give the work to someone who can get it done.

Republicans control this conference for two more months. They should strip Section 815 now, not leave it for Democrats to inherit. Politicians have no business telling the owners of a company how to deploy their own capital. Those decisions belong to boards and shareholders, not to political appointees handing out waivers. If Congress keeps Section 815 in the final bill, our warfighters may regret it sooner than we think.

Pat Toomey, a Republican, served as a U.S. senator from Pennsylvania from 2011-23. He is an adviser to the Capital Freedom Coalition.

Related Content