Supreme Court sitting on emergency petition over Washington’s transgender sports policies

.

The Supreme Court has yet to rule on an emergency petition brought by a female high school wrestler in Washington state last month over state laws that allow biological men to compete in women’s sports, a case that has been complicated by a recently passed state ballot measure.

Kallie Keeler, a biological female wrestler, sued Washington officials after she said she was sexually assaulted by a biological male who identifies as transgender fighter she competed against during a high school girls’ wrestling tournament. She alleged that the state’s policy allowing biological men to compete in women’s sports violates Title IX protections. Keeler, who is represented by the conservative law firm Alliance Defending Freedom, filed her emergency petition with the Supreme Court on Oct. 2, asking the justices to halt the policy or allow her to opt out of competing against male athletes without any athletic penalty, after two lower courts declined.

While the Supreme Court does not have a set timeline for handling emergency petitions, most petitions are typically resolved by the high court within roughly a month. The high court’s general timeline for adjudicating emergency petitions has been accelerated since the explosion of the emergency docket when President Donald Trump returned to the White House in January 2025 and invited an avalanche of lawsuits challenging his policies and actions.

While the case has been pending, voters in Washington approved a ballot measure prohibiting biological boys from competing in certain school athletic programs “intended for female students only” by a nearly 12% margin. Despite the measure being passed by voters, state officials appear lukewarm on enforcing it, and activists have already sued to try to invalidate it. Washington Attorney General Nick Brown, a Democrat and an opponent of the measure, appointed a private law firm to defend the ballot measure on behalf of the state in a lawsuit.

Keeler’s lawyers told the Supreme Court in a letter filed on the docket earlier this month that despite vocal opposition from school boards over the voter-approved measure and ongoing lawsuits seeking to stop the ballot measure from taking effect on Dec. 3, the Supreme Court should still grant their emergency petition.

“This Court should grant K.M.K.’s motion for an injunction pending appeal. That injunction would protect K.M.K. during the impending wrestling season. And other Washington girls who suffer similar injuries could rely on the Court’s decision to seek the emergency relief they likewise need,” John Bursch, a lawyer for ADF, said in a letter to the high court.

Officials from the Washington attorney general’s office disputed ADF’s claims that the issue remains live, claiming the ballot measure will likely take effect as scheduled and resolve the issues Keeler has with the state’s women’s sports policies.

In emergency docket cases, the Supreme Court can issue a decision at any time, but unless there is a specific deadline requested by the petitioner, the high court typically releases rulings on emergency petitions during normal business hours.

SUPREME COURT WEIGHS REQUEST TO PROTECT FEMALE HIGH SCHOOL WRESTLER FROM COMPETING AGAINST MALE ATHLETES

The Supreme Court ruled that states may bar biological men from women’s sports with its June ruling in West Virginia v. B.P.J., adjudicating laws in Idaho and West Virginia, but it did not address whether laws that allow biological men to compete in women’s sports are unlawful. That issue appears poised to make its way to the Supreme Court in the coming years, with Keeler’s case potentially providing a path for the high court to rule on the matter.

Next month, the high court will weigh in on a different law regarding transgender people in Washington when it hears oral arguments in International Partners for Ethical Care, Inc. v. Ferguson. The case centers on a law that allows runaway minors to receive transgender surgeries without parental permission, in addition to exempting the state from a requirement to inform the parents of their child’s location and condition, by making genital and chest surgeries a “protected health care service.” Oral arguments for that case are set for Dec. 7, with a decision expected by the end of June 2027.

Related Content