Welcome to Monday’s edition of Washington Secrets. We have read all the stories about Stephen Miller’s popularity with the MAHA crew, but allow us today to introduce a note of skepticism: Two leaders hint at tensions within the movement and where its voters might go next. Plus, did you notice Rupert Murdoch fired the starting pistol on the 2028 Republican nomination race? And could the 20-hour flight to the Philippines today be any more uncomfortable for two Cabinet secretaries?
The Make America Healthy Again movement came to Washington promising to shake up the food and pharmaceutical industries. Nearly 22 months into Donald Trump’s presidency, some of its leaders are wondering whether Washington has shaken them up instead.
The departure of White House chief of staff Susie Wiles, whom MAHA activists blamed for putting big business first, may offer a fresh opening. But a more consequential shift may be happening beyond the West Wing, as activists look to Congress, the midterms and Democrats to advance their agenda.
“The Republicans rented these voters. They didn’t buy them wholesale,” Tiffany Cianci, a prominent MAHA activist and former RFK Jr. campaign adviser, told Secrets. “They had to deliver, or they were always going to lose them.”
It is a neat proposition: Build a movement around food safety, pesticides, and corporate accountability, then make candidates from Left and Right compete for its support.
The midterm election results suggest it remains a work in progress.
KFF polling found that about three in 10 midterm voters supported MAHA. But MAHA-Republican supporters largely voted Republican, while independents who backed the movement favored Republicans by about two-to-one. More than half of the 24 candidates endorsed by MAHA Action lost, according to Fortune.
That is not yet the picture of an independent voting bloc dictating terms to Washington.
Activists see it as a reason to get organized rather than retreat.
Zen Honeycutt, founder of Moms Across America, said her group had made 110 visits to lawmakers, roughly half of them Democrats. They told her they could do more if they held the majority in Congress.
“Well, now they do,” she said.
Imagine, she suggested, a Democratic Congress passing bills to ban paraquat and restrict glyphosate, including the Americans Versus Poisonous Pesticides Act, which she says would restore consumers’ ability to sue chemical companies. Then it would be up to Trump to sign them.
“It truly will be a bipartisan effort to make America healthy again,” she said.
The movement’s frustration with the White House burst into public view with the recent departure of Calley Means from his role as adviser to Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. He accused Wiles of blocking MAHA priorities while cozying up to lobbyists and corporate interests.
Many MAHA activists welcomed Wiles’s exit and the appointment of Stephen Miller as chief of staff, seeing him as more sympathetic to their agenda. But Cianci is in the camp that sees Miller as the “embodiment of the paperclip problem,” like an AI relentlessly pursuing one goal to destruction, and believes Wiles was never really the problem.
“Her existence is indicative of a bigger problem, which is that on both sides of the aisle you have a corporate capture that’s dictating policy, circumventing what the people want,” she said.
That is part of the thinking behind a planned candidate scorecard, similar to the NRA’s approach of rating politicians on their records rather than their party labels.
It follows Cianci’s MAHA Promises scorecard, published ahead of the midterms. Of 42 administration promises, from draining the swamp of vested interests to cleaning up air and water pollution, it found none had been kept, five had been partially kept, and some 37 had been broken.
But if there is tension between MAHA and the president it helped elect, there are signs of strain inside the movement, too.
Honeycutt wants another Kennedy presidential run in 2028.
“I have made that very clear to him,” she said, although she suspects he wants to see through his work at HHS.
Cianci thinks he is unelectable. Kennedy’s pro-Israel stance, she argues, would make it difficult to rebuild the coalition he assembled in 2024, which included younger voters.
MAHA leaders are angry, and they are developing a plan to turn that anger into political leverage. But the midterm elections showed that movement supporters do not automatically become an independent electorate.
Republicans may have rented those voters. The harder task now is persuading them that they can take their ballots elsewhere.
You are reading Washington Secrets, a guide to power and politics in D.C. and beyond. It is written by Rob Crilly. You can reach him at [email protected] with your comments, story tips, and suggestions.
Rupert Murdoch makes his 2028 move
Did you see Marco Rubio’s speech to the Federalist Society on Friday? You may well have done, given that Fox News took the unusual step of carrying it in full — an honor it did not afford to the President of the United States towards the end of the midterm campaign. (My colleague Kaelan Deese’s take on the speech is here.)
My colleague Kaelan Deese’s take on the speech is here.)
The network even previewed what might otherwise have been the sort of speech left to the C-Spans of this world, and labeled it with a headline quoting an attendee who called him a “visionary” leader. The coverage explicitly pointed out that it was his first big speech since the midterm “blowout,” and it put it all in terms of the 2028 race. What could it all mean?
In journalism circles, this is called “framing.” And it could not have been more obvious: Rupert Murdoch is putting his clout behind Rubio as Republicans try to work out where they go from here.
The segment included heaps of warm words.
“I don’t know anything about who’s going to run in 2028, but what I appreciate about Secretary Rubio is he is traveling all around the country and all around the world to talk about the importance of American values, what binds us, what brings us all together, and the importance of our Constitution,” said Eric Wessan, Iowa solicitor general. “And I’m just excited to hear what he has to say about this amazing document, 250 years in.”
One Republican strategist messaged Secrets to say: “A full segment of compliments. Murdoch is in the tank for Rubio.”
If that wasn’t enough, there was a full panel discussion of the speech and Rubio’s 2028 hopes on Sunday, with a poll saying that 45% of Republicans thought he would make an excellent presidential candidate, some 2 percentage points ahead of Vice President JD Vance.
The Fox News coverage adds to similar work being done by his newspapers, the New York Post and the Wall Street Journal. The former has already run a glowing profile of Rubio, and the latter has published a string of editorials critical of Vance.
Oh to be a fly on the wall
On Friday, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent dropped a bomb on Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick’s head, accusing his colleague of being the weak link in failing to blacklist Nvidia customer Megaspeed, despite allegations that it was at the center of the spy scandal that brought down Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang.
It adds to the pressure on Lutnick, who has long courted controversy and is one of the favorites to be dismissed from the Cabinet this year.
Today, they are both on Air Force One flying with the president to the Philippines, according to the White House. For roughly 20 hours…
Lunchtime reading
Republicans Have Two Paths Out of This. They’d Better Choose Wisely: This is a few days old, but Secrets is a dinosaur and likes to read things in the Sunday paper. One point, however: It was slightly disingenuous to get a representative from one of those two sides to write the piece…
JK Rowling’s agent is betting on the books that publishers won’t touch: Neil Blair is launching a new publishing house. He will have to walk the line between becoming a haven for authors unfairly sidelined and becoming the “island of misfit toys.”
