Abigail Spanberger and the children

.

Gov. Abigail Spanberger (D-VA) dealt a blow to families on Friday when she announced she would block students in her state from accessing new K-12 resources and refuse to participate in the new Federal Scholarship Tax Credit. One powerful group — the teachers union — pressured her to take this stand.

Within hours, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent was up on social media pointing out that Spanberger was breaking the law. Let the lawsuits begin.

This clash was perhaps unavoidable. Spanberger’s predecessor, Glenn Youngkin, had created a dilemma for her. Before she took office in January 2026, he filed the initial paperwork that would allow K-12 scholarships to flow to students enrolled in Virginia’s public and private schools.

To complete the process, Spanberger merely had to provide a list to the Treasury Department of the qualified nonprofit organizations — known as scholarship granting organizations — that would be permitted to distribute K-12 scholarships in the Commonwealth. She has until Feb. 15 of next year to submit that list.

For a governor who wants to make life more affordable, Youngkin’s action could have been seen as a gift. Virginia’s students need the resources, and Virginia families would appreciate having extra money to help guide their children’s education.

But here is her dilemma: providing that SGO list would upset the leadership of the national and state teacher unions. In the world of Democratic politics, where the teachers unions are a superpower, that’s no average dilemma. The union has a long record of ending the political careers of people who cross them.

Spanberger, like the teachers unions, calls these scholarships a “voucher.” She’s wrong. It’s not a voucher because these scholarships will be used by public school children, mostly for tutoring and after-school programs. Sure, some families will use scholarships for nonpublic school options, but that’s not where most students are enrolled. And by the way, governor, what’s so terrible about a family choosing a private or religious school?

It’s also not a voucher because of how these scholarships will be funded. The money is not a government appropriation. Instead, scholarships are funded by voluntary donations from taxpayers, whose charitable contributions are incentivized by a dollar-for-dollar tax credit.

Spanberger should also understand that the unions are perpetuating another myth. Because the donations are voluntary and apply against federal tax revenue, their claim that this federal tax credit will decrease state tax revenues is absurd.

Also like the teachers unions, Spanberger says she doesn’t believe scholarships will go to public school children. Again, she’s wrong. Several SGOs were gearing up to serve public school students in her state. Ironically, the only reason Virginia’s public school students won’t get scholarships is that she won’t allow it.

She also acts like she would have no power to shape Virginia’s scholarship program. Again, so wrong. She could use her powerful office to point taxpayer donors to programs she favors, and that’s exactly what other Democratic governors are doing. Some are even using their payroll system to let the state’s teachers and other government workers direct their scholarship contributions to their favorite programs.

She also conceals that Virginia taxpayers who want to claim the federal tax credit can still do so starting in 2027. Taxpayers will simply donate to SGOs in other states. Virginians can expect fundraising requests soon from SGOs in New York, North Carolina, Florida, and some 30 other states.

Spanberger likely understands exactly why the teachers unions oppose these scholarships. The unions are ideologically opposed to parents choosing any non-public school (which are harder to unionize). They irrationally worry that if families could afford private schools, they and taxpayers would abandon traditional public schools. For them, it’s easier to keep families trapped in zoned schools than to take the steps needed to transform public schools into institutions that would attract every family.

But ideology is only part of their concern. When money flows to families in the form of scholarships, it’s no longer on the bargaining table. And the bargaining table is where the teachers unions derive their power and influence. It’s why they spend so much of their union revenue on electing the people who will be on the other side of that table. It’s smart, even if children lose out.

NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS, ILLINOIS

Spanberger will try to hide behind the unpopularity of “vouchers” and President Donald Trump (who supports these scholarships) as her reasons for rejecting them. Virginians should understand those are fig leaves.

Spanberger still has time to reconsider. Now she must decide: Support Virginia’s students, or support her own political ambitions.

Jim Blew is an adviser to the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit, which supports successful implementation of the tax credit in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. He is a former U.S. assistant secretary of education.

Related Content