The last time a Chinese leader walked out to meet a foreign leader at his plane, the plane was Soviet. Mao Zedong greeted Nikita Khrushchev in 1959.
On Wednesday, 67 years later, Chinese President Xi Jinping did it again. He waited at the foot of Air Force One’s stairs in Shenzhen, embraced President Donald Trump, and stood beside him as both anthems played and fighter jets flew overhead.
Putin had landed shortly after 2 a.m. He was met by Cai Qi.
Cai Qi is a serious man. He runs Xi’s office and ranks fifth on the Politburo Standing Committee. Izvestia’s correspondent assured Russian viewers the welcome was worthy of a state visit. The South China Morning Post noted no other arriving leader had been met by anyone so senior. Both statements held until Air Force One landed.
Both men have been upgraded since May, when Beijing sent its vice president to Trump’s plane and its foreign minister to Putin’s. Only one was upgraded to Xi, who was repaying Trump’s welcome at Joint Base Andrews in September. Reciprocity is a ranking, too. Putin did get two private hours with Xi on Wednesday, their 50th meeting by one estimate. In private, Beijing consoles Moscow. In public, it ranks it.
A ballet instead of an anthem
At the banquet, Trump walked in to the American national anthem. Putin walked in to the Trepak, the Russian dance from Tchaikovsky’s Nutcracker.
In the Kremlin’s own footage, Putin walks up the red carpet to find Trump already standing with Xi and his wife, Peng Liyuan. In the group photo, Trump stood at Xi’s shoulder. Putin, on the far side of Peng. Bloomberg called it Putin’s return from isolation. He returned one spouse removed from the host.
Trump and Xi went in to dinner together. Trump sat beside Xi. Putin, NPR reported, was seated at a separate table. Putin’s aide Yuri Ushakov explained why the two never talked over the meal: “They did not sit next to each other at the table.” Perhaps the Kremlin’s most honest understatement all year.
On the summit’s eve, Russian experts predicted Putin would get a photo with the big boys and nothing more. Half right. He got the photo. He did not get the place in it.
Russian state TV ran footage of the three leaders together, seemingly on a loop, NPR noted, and went looking for other pictures. Outside Putin’s hotel, Russia-1 host Yevgeny Popov gestured at a naval officer’s case and told viewers it was the nuclear briefcase. The officer smiled and confirmed it. “Unbelievable,” Popov said. The day Putin flew in, two nuclear-capable Tu-95 bombers flew past Japan and Taiwan to Vietnam. When protocol fails, wave the briefcase.
When the briefcase fails, decode the ties. A Lenta.ru headline announced that “the secret meaning” of the two presidents’ tie colors had been revealed. Its etiquette expert then said there was no hidden subtext.
The next day, all three sat at one table for 90 minutes. Nuclear arsenals get you into the meeting. They do not get you the host’s table.
I spent 12 years in Georgia’s security services. In Moscow, as in Beijing, a seating chart is a ranking: published, signed by no one, and understood by everyone. Kremlin-friendly commentators spent the week promising a new Yalta. At Yalta, China was on the menu, not at the table. This time, China owned the table and seated each guest by what he can do for China and to it.
What each guest can do to China
Two U.S. carrier strike groups now back a blockade of Iranian ports. Most of Iran’s oil went to China. Venezuela sent most of its crude to China last year. This year, the Energy Information Administration reports, none. America is its biggest customer. On Nov. 5, Washington sanctioned two Chinese firms accused of supplying Cuba’s military. Mexico, Nicaragua, Brazil, even Canada: There is always a forgotten file to reopen, a hemisphere away from wherever Beijing is looking.
The same map runs through my part of the world. On Nov. 6, Chinese Vice President Han Zheng, the man Beijing sent to Trump’s plane in May, landed in Tbilisi. That day, Washington, Yerevan, and Baku launched planning groups for the Trump Route for International Peace and Prosperity. In October, Secretary of State Marco Rubio met all five Central Asian foreign ministers. On the road from the Caspian to the Black Sea, Beijing and Moscow have one government left they can count on without a hedge: Georgia’s. Its patron, Bidzina Ivanishvili, has been under U.S. sanctions since the Biden Treasury Department designated him in December 2024. Its prime minister personally saw Han off at the airport.
The bill comes home
For Putin, the pressure has a home address. Ukraine hit the Kerch Bridge, which Putin opened in 2018 by driving a truck across it, three times in four days. On Nov. 17, it dropped the road arch into the strait. Road traffic stopped. The rail span was damaged. Putin flew to China without a word about it. In July, I wrote here that Ukraine had closed the Sea of Azov without a fleet. Now the arch over the shipping channel lies in it. If it stays, the Azov ports and the Volga-Don waterway have lost their door to the Black Sea.
A week earlier, Ust-Luga, Russia’s biggest Baltic port, burned. This month, I wrote that Russia counts its bears but not its dead, and has begun cutting the payments that come with the coffins. A regime that survives by hiding the war’s cost is mailing the bill home.
In October, Trump handed Putin a deal with a loaded gun beside it. The Trump Treasury Department licensed Russian diesel, and Trump waived key provisions of the late Sen. Lindsey Graham’s sanctions law, whose tariffs of up to 100% target the biggest buyers of Russian energy, China first among them. The tankers sailed, then turned away one by one, the last about 400 nautical miles off New York. Putin got his diesel order. He could not deliver a drop.
A waiver is an operational pause, not a repeal. The gun is still on the table, pointed at two capitals: Moscow, and the biggest buyer of Moscow’s oil.
The quiet front
On Nov. 12, Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia’s chief executive amid reports about his relationship with Alice Huang, a former executive of Megaspeed, a Singapore firm under criminal investigation over possible chip diversion to China. U.S. intelligence reportedly suspects her of spying for China. Beijing denies it. The Justice Department has reached no conclusion. Trump, who said in May that “we spy like hell on them, too,” now says, “I don’t know that she’s a Chinese spy.”
In Shenzhen, Bloomberg’s Annmarie Hordern called out to Trump, asking whether Huang had been “disloyal to the United States.” Trump did not answer. Beijing did: Chinese officials barred her from the trilateral despite a White House push to let her in, and told the press pool that shouting questions is “extremely rude.” On the flight home, reporters aboard Air Force One had to surrender their phones “for security reasons.” Nobody said which.
Here is a hypothesis, not a finding. A service that has turned an agent never exposes her. A service that has only watched a channel, or fed it, can expose it when it suits, and the other side must ask what else is known, which contacts are burned, and which reports were planted. I used to provoke exactly that: When evidence on hostile officers ran dry, I let it circulate that we knew where and how they worked, then watched who moved to check. Nervous services make noise. Noise can be followed.
I have no evidence the FBI did anything of the kind, and I do not claim it did. But in May, two days before Trump landed in Beijing, prosecutors announced charges against the mayor of Arcadia, California, for acting as an illegal agent of China. She has since pleaded guilty. Beijing reads the calendar, too.
Whether North Korean Leader Kim Jong Un came, Trump said, was “up to President Xi.” Not Putin, for whom North Korean soldiers bled in Kursk. Kim stayed home, inspecting a naval university. Xi could not deliver him, or would not. Either answer is intelligence.
So is the trilateral “Declaration toward Peace.” It never mentions Ukraine, Iran, or North Korea. It does pledge more “refined petroleum products.” Putin’s diesel never reached New York. And it defends “the immunities of State officials,” warning the International Criminal Court not to “abuse” its jurisdiction: a direct gift to Putin, wanted by that court since 2023. Washington, which has sanctioned the court’s own officials, gave up nothing to sign it.
Xi opened the trilateral with a warning: “When great powers clash, the world is in chaos.” The question is who controls it. I call Trump’s method controlled chaos, and its signature move aikido: Flatter the strongman in words, squeeze him in deeds, and let his own weight do the rest.
Trump called Xi “an incredible leader.” Approaching Putin, he said, “Who is he? He’s my friend.” Poland’s Donald Tusk posted on X, naming no one: “God, protect us from such friends.” Tusk heard the words. Putin has been reading the deeds since October. Trump told Xi, “As long as you and I are in charge of things, we’re never going to have a problem.” Note the pronouns. Beijing’s protocol showed which guest it can afford to snub.
NPR concluded that the summit’s key deliverable was “arguably the image itself.” Look closer. Moscow came to Shenzhen for a new Yalta. It got Cai Qi at the airport, the Nutcracker at the door, Madame Peng in the photograph, a seat out of earshot at dinner, and about 40 minutes with Trump on the day Ukraine hit his bridge for the third time. Putin, a Kremlin aide said, left “in an excellent mood.”
TERRORISTS DON’T RESPECT BOUNDARIES. MAMDANI IS REDRAWING THEM
Then the excellent mood met the press. “After the strikes on the Crimean bridge, there will be no negotiations,” Putin said. He also defended Yalta, which “merely codified the existing reality,” and said today’s conflicts, too, must come to terms with the realities on the ground. Ukraine’s foreign minister, Andrii Sybiha, named one: Russia “has practically lost its bridge to the real Yalta.” Here is another. That same day, Trump’s envoys were in Berlin with Zelensky and the Europeans. At Yalta, nobody invited the Poles.
The pressure was the message. The seating chart was the receipt.
Emzari Gelashvili is a San Francisco–based geopolitical analyst and columnist who monitors Russian-language media. From 1996 to 2008, he held senior positions in Georgia’s Ministry of State Security, Ministry of Defense, and Ministry of Internal Affairs, with a counterintelligence career focused on Russian and Iranian intelligence operations, and he was a member of the Georgian Parliament from 2008 to 2012. His work appears in Newsweek, the Hill, the Washington Examiner, RealClearDefense, RealClearWorld, RealClearEducation, and RealClearPolicy, and at emzargelashvili.substack.com.
