A federal appeals court extended a block on a lower court’s order that would have restored Temporary Protected Status for Venezuela on Wednesday after the Trump administration went to the Supreme Court hours earlier to seek the justices’ intervention.
Earlier this year, the Supreme Court gave the Trump administration a key win in legal battles over ending TPS, effectively finding that its decisions to end TPS for people from different countries cannot be reviewed by a court. Despite the win, several federal courts were slow to lift their blocks or tried to find other ways to prevent TPS from ending.
In the Venezuela case, a federal judge’s long-dormant order restoring TPS was set to go into effect Friday, with an administrative stay by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit set to expire and no movement on the court’s docket.
The Trump administration went to the Supreme Court to ask for intervention to avoid having to restore TPS, accusing the appeals court of “gamesmanship” by apparently trying to allow the district court’s order to go into effect through inaction. Hours after that emergency petition was filed at the high court, a three-judge panel on the Ninth Circuit issued a brief order halting the federal district court’s ruling until at least seven days after an eventual full ruling by the panel on the Trump administration’s appeal.
The appeals court’s ruling negates the need for the Supreme Court to need to intervene for now, as it keeps TPS revoked in the interim. The Ninth Circuit’s eventual full ruling could be appealed to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court’s June ruling in cases over the termination of TPS for Haiti and Syria found that “the TPS statute plainly bars consideration of respondents’ non-constitutional claims,” and ended most lawsuits challenging the administration’s end of TPS for several other countries, including South Sudan, Somalia, and Venezuela.
CLARENCE THOMAS URGES SUPREME COURT TO REVIEW ‘SENSITIVE PLACES’ GUN LAWS
Since August, all of the Trump administration’s orders terminating TPS for various countries have been allowed to take effect. The final stalled order allowed to take effect concerned Ethiopia and was unblocked by U.S. District Judge Brian Murphy, an appointee of former President Joe Biden, on Aug. 18.
The Trump administration has been overwhelmingly successful in immigration cases on the Supreme Court’s merits docket, with wins on key issues regarding the president’s aggressive immigration enforcement agenda. In the coming months, the high court will hear oral arguments in cases over the Trump administration’s third-country deportation policy and its mandatory detention policy for illegal immigrants. Rulings in the cases this term are expected by the end of June 2027.
