I’ve coached youth football and rugby for more than a decade, and every league I’ve worked with ran on one dull rule. The person who approves the spending doesn’t get paid by the spending. Everyone in youth sports has met the guy who figured he was the exception.
Baltimore’s school board never got that memo. On Sept. 30, FBI agents searched the offices of two organizations led by school commissioner Mujahid Muhammad, and he resigned hours later. A source told the Baltimore Banner that the warrant concerned the Anti-Kickback Statute, which bars paying for referrals of federal healthcare business, and possible money laundering. Muhammad hasn’t been charged, and I’m not here to convict anyone. The public record alone shows how a local government ends up serving itself, and that story needs no indictment.
Mayor Brandon Scott appointed Muhammad in May 2023. In June 2025, the board voted 8-0 on a three-year, $21 million mental health contract split among 11 vendors, including his company, KEYS Development. A district letter first said he voted, then corrected itself to show he abstained. His disclosure forms for 2023 and 2024 did not fully list his roles at KEYS Development and its sister nonprofit group, and the gap went uncorrected until this year.
Nobody had to dig. Company social media posts show him with officials, including the mayor who appointed him, and a district spokeswoman says the ethics panel had already reviewed those forms. Asked whether the eight members who voted knew about his KEYS role, the district did not directly answer. The conflict sat in plain view, and nothing happened.
State auditors found a second problem. Maryland’s inspector general for health determined in April that KEYS Empowers owes the state a six-figure sum from an $824,000 grant and questioned spending on seafood dining, personal apparel, and VR games. Medicaid has separately paid KEYS Development more than $61 million since 2015. Payments and audit findings aren’t proof of fraud, but they show the scale.
Recusal fixes one vote and leaves the relationship untouched. Anirban Basu, who served on that board from 2005 to 2011, said it plainly: “The fact that he recused himself does not solve the problem.” As an expert witness in fiduciary cases, I’ve read the paperwork conflicts leave behind. Thirty years in investment management gave me a napkin rule: eliminate the conflict, or disclose it early and fully, and never let an abstention stand in for either.
Maryland already requires school boards to adopt conflict-of-interest rules for their own members, and Baltimore’s board has a Code of Ethics. The rules existed. Enforcement rested on a board policing itself. James Madison spotted that flaw in 1787: “No man is allowed to be a judge in his own cause,” he wrote in Federalist No. 10, because interest bends judgment. Baltimore also hasn’t had a Republican mayor since 1967, and I won’t claim my side has a monopoly on virtue. But a city with no serious rival has no one eager to ask the awkward question. Baltimore already gave us The Wire. Apparently the writers’ room is still open.
Defenders will say the district’s payments were modest, Muhammad sat out the vote, the district ended the contract, and an ethics review is under way. All true, and that review is still pending. But modest sums are the best argument for a clean rule, since a clean rule costs almost nothing. A system where federal agents arrive before the ethics panel finishes has a design flaw.
TO SURVIVE, THE GOP CANNOT BECOME LIKE THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY
Fix it with three rules any volunteer league would recognize. Ban it outright: No commissioner, and no company a commissioner owns or runs, sells to the district, with no waivers. Publish it: Post every disclosure online and check it yearly against IRS filings and state business records; work a television station managed with public data. Audit it: Hire an independent reviewer to list every vendor tied to a commissioner, and make the appointing mayor say what vetting came first.
Any treasurer who tried to sell my teams their jerseys wouldn’t last a season. Baltimore’s children get a board held to a lower standard. Taxpayers should expect to learn about conflicts from the district, not the FBI.
Jay Rogers is a financial professional with more than 30 years of experience in private equity, private credit, hedge funds, and wealth management. He writes about issues in finance, constitutional law, national security, human nature, and public policy.
