The real reason why the internet is crashing at our feet

.

Is cyberspace collapsing? Sure seems that way. Microsoft goes down worldwide. Jet travel grinds to a halt. FEMA goes down. It’s no secret that the NSA, which keeps the secrets, lost its internet. United Airlines again stopped all flights. Everything from the BBC and CNN to Zoom, Salesforce, and Equifax got hacked. All in five days. Coincidence? Terrorism? Bad luck? Or all of the above?

In coming weeks, we’ll learn whether it’s random hackers, the Chinese, or little green men from Mars that have taken down company after company, stolen credit card information, and otherwise caused massive havoc, economic and political, online.

But we still aren’t facing the real reason why security is so insanely weak across cyberspace. It’s because companies never wanted to pay for it. Their cheapness and shortsightedness are causing pain and disruption to every single one of us. And we, the people, let them get away with it.

So the question arises: if security is so important to businesses and government agencies, why has it proven so pathetically weak?

A little history is in order. The Defense Department created the internet to provide a communications network in the event that the phone system went down. The web was promptly gobbled up by idealistic Silicon Valley ex-hippies who believed, in a very 1960s, kumbaya way, that the internet would police itself.

Yeah, that never happened.

Then the business world discovered they could sell practically anything online, if only we’d type our credit card data into websites. People had to be convinced it was just as safe as giving their actual credit card to a restaurant waiter. Once that trust was created, Amazon and its progeny were born.

Eventually, we all bought in, and now we even keep our credit cards in cyberspace, where they’re allegedly secure. Turns out, nothing’s safe at all, and anyone with a ninth-grade tech education can steal pretty much anything.

From the 1990s on, companies had the option of spending extra money to pay for higher levels of security for their customers. But they universally declined to do so. And here we are today, with hacks, crashes, theft of information, Bitcoin, and everything not nailed down.

Why didn’t businesses spend the money to keep their customers safe online?

A bunch of reasons.

First, companies sensed that if their systems were compromised, their customers would pay the price, not the companies themselves. If hacked, the companies just paid overtime to their IT people to get systems up and running again. The customers, not the businesses, suffered identity theft, fraud, privacy violations, and endless inconvenience. The businesses get off scot-free.

Second, if you’re a business and you must choose between new features on your website (which everyone sees) and greater security (which no one sees), guess what you’ll choose.

Third, we customers can’t accurately judge whether an online business has good security. We’ll buy stuff from practically anyone if their website is attractive enough. Nobody thinks, “Is this website safe?”

Fourth, companies manage for the quarter, not the distant and unknowable future. No executive ever got rewarded for saying, “Let’s spend money now that won’t pay off until much later, if ever.”

Fifth, security is so boring that companies take the attitude of “We’ll get around to it one day.” And then the day never arrives.

Sixth, companies don’t face financial or criminal penalties for having lousy security, so they have no legal incentive to make it right.

Taken altogether, and the internet is a hacker’s paradise, a smorgasbord of opportunities for theft, disruption, and mayhem. Iranian hackers caused tens of millions of dollars of food to spoil across Europe this month. God knows whether a contractor in Arkansas fouled up the air-traffic control system or the Iranians did it.

In short, nothing, no one, and no dollar, pound, Euro, or Bitcoin is safe.

A lot of this trouble could have been avoided if we’d all been more security-conscious a couple of decades ago. But no one listened to the few people issuing warnings — Columbia Law School Professor Tim Wu comes to mind — and so the world is awash in hacks, online theft, and cyberfraud.

ISRAEL’S CYBERSECURITY FIRMS PROTECT EVERYONE — INCLUDING ANTISEMITES

But we were too busy discovering the joys of online shopping and buying weapons and getaway cars on Grand Theft Auto to pay attention.

Could the internet ever be safe? Only if businesses pay the price. Until then, the real price of identity theft, credit card fraud, and disruptions to our normal existences is what you and I pay every day.

Michael Levin is a two-time New York Times bestselling author. His next novel, 2028, A Political Thriller, will be published by Morgan James in April.

Related Content