DC Circuit weighs Trump’s takeover of two agencies after Supreme Court agency head removal ruling

.

A federal appeals court heard a pair of cases on Tuesday dealing with the Trump administration’s takeover of two government agencies as part of a wave of cases over firings by President Donald Trump that courts had put on pause while the Supreme Court weighed last term whether Trump had sweeping firing powers across the executive branch.

The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 earlier this year in Trump v. Slaughter that the president could fire officials at most independent agencies within the executive branch, but held 5-4 in the case Trump v. Cook that the Federal Reserve was uniquely insulated from the broad at-will firing power the president enjoys over the executive branch. Several cases pending in federal courts over firing within government agencies by the president were put on pause before the Supreme Court’s ruling in Slaughter, including cases over Trump administration removals of members of the U.S. Institute of Peace board and the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board.

A three-judge panel on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit heard arguments Tuesday in both of those cases, which were unfrozen over the summer after the Supreme Court’s ruling. Justice Department lawyers leaned heavily on Slaughter in their arguments for why the removals should be permitted by the appeals court.

“USIP’s activities are analogous to other exercises of the president’s foreign affairs powers by the State Department and other executive branch agencies,” DOJ lawyer McKaye Neumeister told the panel, arguing the U.S. Institute of Peace is under the executive branch. “USIP is thus executive. Therefore, under the Supreme Court’s decision in Slaughter, USIP’s board members must be subject to at-will removal by the president, and the statutory restrictions on their removal are unconstitutional.”

Neumeister faced a grilling from the appeals court panel as the judges questioned how the institute is exerting executive power with its mandate to mitigate conflicts worldwide through its research and operations. The DOJ lawyer responded by pointing out that the president “in general, has power over foreign affairs.”

William Murphy, the lawyer representing the fired board members, argued that the U.S. Institute of Peace is not an executive branch entity and was set up by Congress to be independent, not exercising executive branch powers. The panel of judges were also deeply skeptical of Murphy’s framing, questioning how the institute is separate from the government.

During arguments over the removal of Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board members, the panel of judges were significantly more skeptical of the fired members’ claims that they cannot be subject to at-will removal from the president. Much of the arguments dealt with the lack of clear removal protections in federal law for the board, and whether that is enough for the president to be able to remove members without cause. The appeals court panel appeared more favorable to the Trump administration’s arguments in the case of that board.

The D.C. Circuit panel included U.S. Circuit Judges Karen Henderson, an appointee of former President George H.W. Bush; Cornelia Pillard, an appointee of former President Barack Obama; and Harry Edwards, an appointee of former President Jimmy Carter. The panel did not indicate when or how it would rule.

MISSOURI URGES 8TH CIRCUIT TO REVIVE LAWSUIT OVER STARBUCKS’S DEI POLICIES

The Supreme Court’s Slaughter ruling was one of several cases involving the Trump administration that the high court has taken up over the past two years. The justices have given the administration a mixed record so far. The Slaughter case was one of the biggest wins for the president, but he has faced high-profile losses at the high court in cases over his sweeping tariffs and his bid to modify birthright citizenship.

During the current term, the Supreme Court will hear multiple cases involving the Trump administration, with major cases on immigration policy looming in the coming months. In December, the high court will weigh the legality of the administration’s policy of deporting illegal immigrants to countries other than their country of origin.

Related Content