China lashes out, fearing failed plan to conceal fishing ecocide

.

Beijing is lashing out over its fear of increased international action against Chinese super fleets that are dredging the oceans of fish. The dispute centers on Belgium and Chile’s Nov. 6 decision to combine their bids to host the secretariat for the Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction Agreement. That agreement governs the protection of more than two-thirds of the world’s oceans.

China had pushed hard to secure the secretariat, even offering entirely free office space in its coastal city of Xiamen. The Belgian-Chilean action has put a major damper on these efforts. A Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson issued a diatribe last week, offering six separate complaints about this supposed injustice. But what Beijing really fears is increased global efforts to restrain its rampant overfishing. If China loses this bid, it will face two problems. First, its ability to overfish will be hampered. Second, its activities will draw growing negative attention.

Without serving as the nation supervising global monitoring of the maritime environment, China knows it will be unable to slow-roll action to improve the condition of that environment. For the same reason, Beijing wants to supervise information sharing on the health of the maritime environment — not to improve outcomes, but rather to hide evidence of how badly its fishing fleets behave.

That is why Belgium and Chile deserve firm U.S. and allied support for their bid.

Putting China in charge of this secretariat would be like putting the mafia in charge of the FBI. China’s fishing super fleets are so large that they can be seen from space. And their presence, from the Galapagos Islands and Chile to West Africa and waters around the world, carries heavy costs. As the Washington Examiner has argued, “These fishing fleets are depleting vulnerable fishing stocks, destroying the lives of impoverished local fishermen, and gutting international maritime law. Their actions represent a modern version of piracy. They require forceful riposte.”`

A particular challenge, relevant to Chile’s move to secure the secretariat, is the role of Chinese super fleets in wiping out squid populations off Chile and Argentina. This fishing has depleted squid populations and those of innumerable fish species, disrupted food chains, and drained Latin American economies and local fishing industries.

Yet China has seen no forceful riposte for its actions. On the contrary, when Chinese fishing fleets off the coast of Chile want to go where they are not supposed to or do what they are not supposed to do, they simply turn off their location transponders. When confronted, Beijing screeches that it is being treated with prejudice. Sometimes, but rarely, nations have taken tougher action. The problem is that there is no unified global response. In turn, China is able to use its economic and diplomatic weight to isolate and intimidate individual nations into submission.

This is a real problem that carries broader security relevance. China revels in scouring waters that do not belong to it. And where Beijing believes it can get away with doing so, as in the South China Sea, it uses force to protect its unjust claims.

The correct response is to meet China with similar force. Chile’s submission that Valparaiso host the secretariat would be opportune in this regard. After all, Valparaiso was a key hub for the British Royal Navy in the 19th century, a base from which it contested France in Pacific waters.

In an ideal scenario, the United States would work with Chile, Argentina, and as many other nations as possible to establish guardrails on fishing and ecological protection in international waters. This might involve increased intelligence sharing and joint Coast Guard patrols that actively enforce rules against overfishing. At a minimum, these efforts could produce high-fidelity video of what the fishing fleets are doing, drawing global ire toward Beijing and pressuring it to change course (this strategy has had some effect in boosting support for the Philippines as it faces down Chinese harassment). Where ships turn off transponders and enter protected waters or national exclusive economic zones, their crews and ships could be seized — or, even better, sunk.

IN FOCUS: ‘ARM THE IRANIAN PEOPLE’ IS A SLOGAN, NOT A STRATEGY

We’ll find out in mid-January who has won the race. But while this might seem like a typically peripheral, big-talk, no-relevance U.N. issue, it is anything but. There is a reason China has placed such importance on securing the secretariat — and will almost certainly attempt to bribe nations to do so. It’s because Beijing has much to lose and much to hide.

The world thus has a choice: it can either take a tougher stand against Chinese overfishing, or it can yield to Beijing’s bullying and accept its continuing annihilation of maritime populations.

Related Content