Trump voters have a new crush: Mark Kelly and the Democratic Socialists of America

.

Welcome to Tuesday’s edition of Washington Secrets. Today we bring you intriguing polling numbers from Election Day, which paint a thoroughly confusing picture of a new cohort of voters that could be the key to 2028. Plus, we read Joe Biden’s memoir so you didn’t have to, and we have more on why Donald Trump turned on Susie Wiles.

There is a new breed of swing voter in American politics. They backed Donald Trump in 2024, defected to the Democrats in the 2026 midterm elections, think centrist Sen. Mark Kelly (D-AZ) would make a good president, and have warm feelings toward the Democratic Socialists of America.

Decoding this strange new group could be crucial to winning the White House in 2028.

Those are the intriguing findings of a new poll from J.L. Partners. It surveyed 1,000 voters on Election Day and cross-referenced their attitudes with 30,000 campaign interviews.

Its main takeaway was that two-thirds of the 15-point Democratic swing came down to Trump supporters simply staying home. But that blue wave became a rout when another chunk of his voters switched sides.

And that chunk seems to defy simple labels. Kelly scored the highest among possible Democratic candidates when they were asked about 2028, with a net favorability of +36, yet those same voters also said they liked candidates associated with the DSA by a net favorability of +17 (44% favorable and 27% unfavorable). In contrast, the wider sample of voters still preferred Kelly, with a net favorability of +13%, while DSA had a negative net favorability.

So the headlines might be about turnout, but plotting the future of American politics may come down to understanding this new grouping.

They skew young, male, urban, and independent, although 36% now identify as Democrats. They still are more favorably disposed towards Trump (-6) than the wider population (-14). They remain net positive towards the Republican Party (+6), but are even warmer towards the Democrats (+43).

“In politics you either rebuild the coalition you had, or find a new one,” said James Johnson, who ran the poll. “If the Republican Party wants to do the former, then it has to win these defectors back. The challenge is they upend most of our assumptions about how Americans vote.

“They are at once broadly positive about the Republican Party and also sympathetic to the policies of the DSA. Divining them is going to need to be the priority of both parties if they want to win back the White House.”

For Democrats, could Kelly be the answer? He outranks Cory Booker (+30), Wes Moore (+28) and Josh Shapiro (+27) among the defectors, although the differences are within the poll’s margin of error.

One Democratic strategist said the Arizona senator was in some ways the “ideal candidate.”

“He is something that Democrats have desperately needed, and that’s the ability to appeal to people who don’t always vote Democratic,” they said. “We can spend a lot of time trying to figure out how to win those voters back, or we can look at someone who’s already doing it.”

Veteran Democratic political strategist Steve Jarding points to Kelly’s unusual political resume.

“First of all, he’s elected in a swing state. That’s not lost on anybody these days,” he said. “But more importantly, his military background and his background as an astronaut still play favorably in America.”

The results come with something of a health warning. The poll found only 87 defectors, so their thoughts on the DSA carry a generous margin of error (at 10.5 points).

But coupled with the fact that some 30% of all respondents said they did not believe the Democrats had a candidate ready to be president, the data reflect a sense that voters are not looking for a return to the “same old, same old,” as the strategist put it.

“It’s like Democrats are borrowing these voters,” they said, “and if they don’t do something that appeals to them, then these voters are going to go back someplace else.”

You are reading Washington Secrets, a guide to power and politics in D.C. and beyond. It is written by Rob Crilly. You can reach him at [email protected] with your comments, story tips, and suggestions.

Kamala’s switcheroo

Life is too short to read presidential memoirs. The takeaway is always: things would have gone much better if only you’d done what I said … which can refer to Cabinet secretaries, Congress, or voters.

Joe Biden’s Promise Me, America is no exception. But there are some fun nuggets. It is interesting to see that his decision to pardon Hunter is relegated to the endnotes, for example, and presidential historians will sift through the subtext, seeing Biden position himself as leader of the Democratic Party, only to realize that the party has little interest in being led by him.

And then there is the minutiae of putting together a presidential run. Such as: How do you maintain secrecy when you are interviewing possible running mates? In the case of Kamala Harris, it involved Annie Tomasini, a key Biden staffer, at a clandestine rendezvous point.

In this case, a member of Senator Harris’s staff drove her to a shopping center in McLean, Virginia. Annie met them, and Senator Harris hopped from one car to the other. Together they drove to the house my family had rented nearby, overlooking the Potomac.

It’s the latest in a rich tradition of subterfuge.

Perhaps the most famous recent episode comes from 2012, when the son of an adviser to Mitt Romney picked up Paul Ryan and drove him to a secret meeting in his parents’ dining room. Ryan had earlier given reporters the slip by waving to them outside his home, heading inside, then walking straight out the back door and through the woods before being collected by his chief of staff.

Susie Wiles’ downfall?

New York Times reporter Maggie Haberman, who has covered Trump since his New York property days, has a theory for why the president turned on his righthand woman.

She told “Raging Moderates” podcast host Jessica Tarlov that it was Susie Wiles’s diagnosis of cancer that marked the start of her fall from grace.

“She wasn’t physically as present, she tried working through it. People knew that she wasn’t there, and Trump does not like… illness. He sees it as weakness. And so, he started picking on her,” Haberman said.

Plus, Secrets can tell you that proximity to Trump is power. Being less present makes it harder to defend against the constant whispers from other courtiers seeking favor.

Wiles revealed her diagnosis in February. She left in the immediate aftermath of the midterm election wipeout.

Lunchtime reading

Why this week’s meeting of world leaders won’t be Yalta 2.0: They are not the winners in a global conflict. In fact, two of them are bogged down in wars of their own choosing.

The Circus is back in town: John Le Carre’s son has picked up the torch, and George Smiley is back in business. With very satisfying results, according to this review.

Related Content