Ranked choice voting is rank stupidity

.

Get used to the acronym RCV. Although ranked choice voting has been used in scattered municipal elections throughout the country for more than 20 years, it is still a new way for voters to choose candidates in most of the United States. From dog catcher up through the presidency, about 98% of all elected officials wear an “R” or “D” label, sometimes hidden under the collar in local elections where all run as independents.

Using RCV does not increase the chance of a smaller third-party candidate winning an election, but it does give these office seekers a stronger presence on the campaign trail. Voters mark their ballots with first, second, third (and so on) choices for all those running for each office. If no candidate gets more than half the vote, the second-place votes of the candidate who came in last are then included in the tally. This transfer of votes continues from the bottom of the candidate pile upward until one candidate emerges with over half the vote.

There are three advantages to RCV. First, money is saved because runoff elections are eliminated. (For this reason, RCV is sometimes called instant runoff voting.) Second, in elections without runoffs, candidates cannot win with a plurality, that is, less than 50% of the votes. Third, candidates outside the two major parties who help expand the overall political debate can no longer act as spoilers. For example, if RCV had been in place in Florida during the 2000 presidential race, most of Ralph Nader’s votes would likely have been transferred to Al Gore who then would have defeated George W. Bush.

But drawbacks abound. RCV advocates tend to be sophisticated political animals who can not only rattle off all the names of their county supervisors but have also sent them boatloads of emails requesting city or state funds for the nonprofit organizations they run. In short, almost all RCV backers live in Progressive City. When they introduce proposals to their legislators to switch over to ranked choice voting, they are overwhelmingly supported by Democrats while equal numbers of Republicans oppose the measures. One notable exception: In 2019 Gov. Gavin Newsom (D-CA) expressed concern that RCV “has often led to voter confusion, and that the promise that [RCV] leads to greater democracy is not necessarily fulfilled.”

RCV devotees had the wind at their backs for a few years as the practice slowly gained traction in city elections, then got an even bigger slice of the pie in 2022 when it busted out in Alaska and Maine at the statewide level. But that double win was followed two years later in 2024 with significant setbacks, according to an analysis from the University of Illinois’s Institute of Government and Public Affairs. Ballot measures in six states attempting to introduce RCV failed and Nevada reversed its 2022 approval. The number of states banning RCV grew from five to 17.

At this moment in the race for a U.S. Senate seat in Alaska, RCV madness is in play. Former Democratic Rep. Mary Peltola holds a narrow lead over Sen. Dan S. Sullivan (R-AK). With slightly over 90% of the votes counted, she is ahead with 49.2% of the vote to Sullivan’s 47%. It is possible but most unlikely she will emerge with more than half the votes when the counting is complete, thus pulling the RCV trigger. The tabulation will begin on Nov. 18 and is expected to be completed on or before Nov. 25.

IRAN IS TRYING TO KILL OUR LEADERS. HOW WILL IMPEACHING PETE HEGSETH MAKE AMERICA SAFER?

Among the ranked choice candidates with zero chance of winning is Dan J. Sullivan, who could easily be confused with Dan S. Sullivan. That, say Republicans, is the point. They allege, and with good reason, “Decoy Dan,” as they call him, is a Democratic plant closely linked to Peltola’s campaign. On top of that, another zero chancer and perennial Republican candidate for various offices in Alaska, Gerald Heikes, is also running for the Senate seat. He is a minister who is best known for his constitutional conservative Christian identity.

As of this writing, Peltola is 5,800 votes ahead of Sullivan. Out of about 250,000 votes counted so far, Dan J. Sullivan has 4,200 votes and Heikes has 5,490. While unlikely, these three numbers set up the delicious possibility RCV will backfire on the progressives. When transferred, in theory, virtually all of Decoy Dan and Heikes’s votes should go to Dan S. Sullivan. Here’s hoping he returns to Capitol Hill.

Bob Armstrong is a contributing writer for Thursday Review, an online magazine, and the author of a memoir, No Exit From Vietnam (Pen & Sword Books).

Related Content