Flight, fiasco, and finger-pointing

.

One of the greatest compliments I ever received came this October in an interview with John Solomon of Just the News. John opened the interview by saying most government agencies run their leaders, not the other way around. Then he introduced me, implying I had not been held under the thumb of the federal agencies I ran: the Federal Emergency Management Agency and the Department of Homeland Security’s Countering Weapons of Mass Destruction Office. That’s true; I was an alien to them. I don’t like entourages, black SUVs, security, sycophants, the corner office, or obfuscation. John is no flatterer, but I was flattered.

When the interview ended, I handed John a copy of my latest book, Texas Flood, 4 July 2025. He told me he would read it on his flight that weekend. I assume John got there and back with the last page turned. Not so for many who planned to read on a flight this weekend. They read at home.

Knowing what I know about federal agencies, I’m surprised there aren’t more weekends like the past one, where 12,000 or so flights nationwide were grounded or canceled. Late Friday afternoon, the Federal Aviation Administration stopped every departure in the country for more than four hours, with about 3,500 airplanes already aloft. It’s only the second time since Sept. 11, 2001, this has occurred.

Both federal agencies I ran were inefficient, and the federal employees who ran them seemed to have only a vague idea of what they were charged by law to do. I doubt the FAA is much different.

I took both agencies I ran head-on. With the aid of unintended consequences caused by decisions made by those who came before me at CWMD, I was able to put that agency on the course for shutdown. It’s closed today. Had it not been for the delay caused by waiting for the FEMA Review Council to orient itself and, a year later, make a recommendation to President Donald Trump, the agency would be drastically transformed today, and the American people would be better served. Opportunity lost.

Here’s what we know about this past weekend. The FAA says its legacy equipment went unstable when data flooded the network. The initial investigation points to a radar site where L3Harris was installing a new router. Nobody has said yet whether it was operator error, installation error, or a bad box, or if the FAA signed off on the work.

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy is no slouch. Sean was a competitive lumberjack who raced up an 80-foot pole at the Lumberjack World Championships. Yet, despite his logging prowess, he is likely owned by the federal employees at TSA and FAA. Federal employees are hardened bureaucrats and difficult to outmaneuver.

Here’s how you can tell Sean has succumbed to being run by TSA/FAA. Given the choice between accepting responsibility and turning to the ranks of federal employees to root out causes of mishap, fiasco, or systemic suffering, Duffy placed the blame on L3Harris, a contractor. “They own this network,” he said. “They’re our prime contractor. I can’t go somewhere else.” He has also said many contractors “take our money and provide really poor service.”

The FAA did the same in January 2023, blaming “contract personnel” who “unintentionally deleted files.” That’s abdication of responsibility because the FAA is supposed to oversee the contractor. Either Duffy doesn’t understand this because he has federal employees whispering in his ear to deflect blame, or, more likely, he’s not inclined to look inward and alienate the faltering federal machine careening down the highway. In either case, federal employees, not the president’s appointee, are calling the shots at the FAA.

Here’s how it’s supposed to work. When cubicle-bound federal bureaucrats who don’t make or operate anything but are charged with keeping the mechanics of commerce, travel, safety, communications, energy, etc., churning, they reach out to industry with written requirements that define the needed capability. A perennial concern of industry, though, is the federal government’s inability to articulate accurate requirements. Because of complacency and lack of critical thinking and writing skills, the federal-employee-developed requirements often miss the mark. This is common knowledge in the federal acquisition community.

Fortunately, industry generally knows the requirements for keeping the nation’s wheels turning far better than federal employees and often steps in and helps develop them. Otherwise, we’d be far deeper in Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged dystopia of incompetence than we are. Yet that does not negate the mandate of federal oversight once a company is hired to implement a solution. Duffy’s finger-pointing implies it does, even though somewhere in the halls, cubicles, latrines, parking spaces, or closets of the FAA, a federal employee is charged with overseeing the program where failure occurred.

L3Harris and its predecessor, Harris, have run the FAA’s telecommunications network since 2002. The FAA awarded Verizon a $2.4 billion contract in 2023 to replace it, then this August put AT&T in the lead instead, without a new competition, saying the old network “can no longer support” air traffic operations. It’s confusing, but that’s normal for bureaucracy and similar to sheiks I watched in Iraq competing for garbage collection contracts — the only difference is the clothes and language.

When there is an incident like this weekend’s, the call is nearly always: We need more money to fix it. Apparently, the fix before the failure was set at $30 billion. When we woke up Saturday, it was $50 billion. That’s just another drop in the bucket of the $40 trillion debt that will turn our children into serfs. Congress gave the FAA $12.5 billion in July 2025; by March, the Government Accountability Office reported, it had obligated $1.8 billion of $9 billion designated for modernizing systems. Nobody ever says: I’ll find the people in my own organization responsible. I’ve done the mission analysis; I know where my organization is broken and what is required of it and not required to do. Let me fix it. I’ll call you if I need money.

When I ran CWMD, I had to explain to the federal employees at all levels what by law they were supposed to do, not what they thought was a good idea. Most were surprised but accepted the facts. My team determined CWMD’s mission could be accomplished better with fewer than 100 federal employees instead of the 500 assigned. This upset the agency, but it was too late. Today, there are around 150 former CWMD personnel floating around DHS doing the mission CWMD once did. Same for FEMA— FEMA thinks its mission is helping people. There is no basis in law for this belief, and that’s why mission creep has turned the agency into a nationwide social services stand staffed by upwards of 18,000, as opposed to the 4,000 who did it in 2006.

Duffy might want to loosen the leash the federal employees at the FAA appear to have on him and search for the lack of oversight from federal employees rather than taking the easy route and blaming contractors.

THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT SAYS LYING UNDER OATH IS PART OF THE JOB

Duffy will not likely do that. He appears full of the Kool-Aid that federal employees have poured into him. It’s rare to be otherwise. In effect, he’s saying, “It’s somebody else’s fault.” That’s the standard federal employee line. Articulating that something is someone else’s fault is nearly a job requirement for being a federal employee; you won’t rise far without blame-shifting being your first instinct.

Blaming contractors will take the heat off, but it won’t remove the problem. The problem is in the ranks. Some know this but dare not tell Duffy. Keeping their job is very likely more important than the safety of the American people.

David Richardson served as a senior official performing the duties of FEMA administrator. He is the author of Texas Flood, 4 July 2025: Power, Money, Politics, History, Bureaucracy and Tragedy.

Related Content