Pardon me, are you a lobbyist?

.

Then-President Joe Biden told reporters in June 2024, “I will not pardon him.” Less than six months later, he pardoned his son Hunter for any federal offense retroactive to Jan. 1, 2014, shortly before his sentencing on gun and tax convictions. I’m a husband, a father of three sons and a taxpayer. I know a broken promise when I see one, because I’ve raised teenagers.

Sen. John Kennedy (R-LA) told Sean Hannity on Wednesday that Republicans should act before Democrats take control of Congress, and he put pardon reform on the list: “Require all pardon brokers to register with the government.” He’s right, and the rule works for any president. Anyone paid to work a pardon should have to say so in public.

The market is real. A 60 Minutes hidden-camera investigation filmed lobbyists Jack Burkman and Jacob Wohl offering to pressure the president for $300,000. CBS’s own analysis found roughly 70% of Trump’s second-term clemency actions skipped the Justice Department’s process. The White House says paying lobbyists for a pardon wastes money, and Burkman and Wohl deny running a pay-to-play operation.

Democrats don’t own this problem. On his last day, Biden preemptively pardoned Dr. Anthony Fauci, retired Gen. Mark Milley, House Jan. 6 committee members and staff, and police officers who testified before it, citing politically motivated prosecutions. In the final minutes of his presidency, he pardoned five relatives, including his brother James, whom House Republicans had urged prosecutors to charge with lying to Congress. A House Republican impeachment report alleged Biden family members and associates received over $27 million from foreign sources. The White House dismissed it as a failed stunt. The pardons make sure no court ever tests the claim. Biden said the family pardons should not be mistaken for an admission of wrongdoing. Right, and I have oceanfront land in Kansas to sell, any buyers?

Two bills would start the job. Sen. Cory Booker (D-NJ) introduced S. 5687 to require anyone paid to secure clemency to register and report their contacts with administration officials, and to make recipients disclose benefits they gave the president, his family or their businesses. It sits in the Judiciary Committee. H.R. 9860, from Rep. Dave Min (D-CA), would make paid clemency lobbyists register within two days of the first contact and report each contact within two days. It has only been introduced.

I testify as an expert witness in fiduciary cases, and the lesson repeats. The questions are always who paid, who knew, and who told the client. Conflicts rarely sink anyone. Hiding them does. The SEC says an adviser must eliminate conflicts of interest or expose them through full disclosure. Upton Sinclair wrote that it’s hard to make a man understand something when his salary depends on not understanding it. A pardon broker’s fee depends on silence.

I coached youth rugby and football for years, so I know lobbying. Parents lobbied me for playing time, for free, mostly in the parking lot, and nobody filed a report. Gordon Gekko told Bud Fox in “Wall Street” that “the most valuable commodity I know of is information.” Pardon brokers sell access. Disclosure puts their inventory on a public shelf.

Critics argue Congress can’t regulate a power the Constitution gives the president. That objection fits bills that second-guess clemency. These don’t. H.R. 9860’s lobbying section amends the Lobbying Disclosure Act, which governs paid advocates, and its other major rule requires the president to publish a written explanation when he acts. Nothing in either bill bans paid advocacy. A president can still pardon whomever he likes. They would just have to explain why.

THE BOOM YOUR PAYCHECK MISSED

The Senate Republican conference unanimously backed Sen. Rick Scott (R-FL)’s motion to stay in Washington, so the calendar is open. Spend some of it on pardon-broker registration, and revisit the stock-trading bill that stalled in the Senate 53-47 on Sept. 30, short of the 60 needed, after Democrats balked at an attached voter ID provision.

Justice Louis Brandeis wrote that “sunlight is said to be the best of disinfectants.” Presidential promises expire on short notice. Public filings stay put. Pardon me, but who paid you? Whoever holds the pen next, the answer belongs to the public.

Jay Rogers is a financial professional with more than 30 years of experience in private equity, private credit, hedge funds, and wealth management. He writes about issues in finance, constitutional law, national security, human nature, and public policy.

Related Content