The nightmare scenario for Republicans next month is not simply losing the House, the Senate, or a handful of governorships. Rather, it is watching a bad political climate elect Democrats who survive for multiple cycles.
As bad as the situation facing the GOP looks, however, there is seldom anything permanent in American politics. I have been doing this long enough to remember 2006, which was an absolute disaster for Republicans, and 2008, when former President Barack Obama’s historic victory prompted confident declarations that the party was finished.
Two years later, Obama’s overreach produced the Tea Party wave of 2010. Republicans reclaimed the House, only for Obama to handily win reelection in 2012. The lesson is that recovering nationally is different from recovering everything lost along the way.
For months, I have argued that 2026 feels like 2006 and, after the financial crisis, 2008. No matter what Republicans say, voters do not seem to be listening. No matter how much money the party spends, its message does not seem to be getting through.
Could the polls be wrong? Certainly. But a volatile political climate is precisely what makes a wave election dangerous. When one party’s coalition is discouraged and the other’s is energized, seemingly safe seats become competitive and long shots become upsets. Local dynamics and weak candidates only make matters worse.
Consider 2006. Democrats won the Senate majority after Republican incumbents were defeated by Claire McCaskill in Missouri, Jim Webb in Virginia, Bob Casey in Pennsylvania, and Jon Tester in Montana.
The GOP needed 12 years to defeat McCaskill. Casey and Tester lasted 18 years before losing in 2024. Webb retired after one term, but his seat was never recovered as Democrat Tim Kaine succeeded him. Webb’s victory was also an early marker of Virginia’s transformation into a blue state.
The hidden cost of a wave is that seats won in the surge do not automatically wash back with the tide.
Georgia offers a better example than Virginia. Sen. Jon Ossoff (D-GA) appears positioned to win a second term in a state that was once safely red. If he wins, the GOP’s next chance will not come until 2032.
Set demographic changes aside. By 2032, Ossoff would have spent nearly 12 years establishing himself in the Senate. That assumes he has not become president, vice president, or a Cabinet secretary.
Texas is even more consequential. Polling shows Democrat James Talarico ahead of Republican Ken Paxton in the Senate race. Texas Democrats have seen this movie before, with Wendy Davis in 2014 and Beto O’Rourke in 2018. But if Talarico wins, defeating him once he is an incumbent will be a herculean task.
The stakes extend beyond the Senate. Imagine a blue wave powerful enough to oust incumbent Gov. Greg Abbott (R-TX). Texas would instantly be in play in the 2028 presidential election. The last Democrat to win the state was Jimmy Carter in 1976. Without Texas in their Electoral College column, it would be mathematically impossible for Republicans to win the presidency.
None of this makes incumbents invincible. McCaskill, Casey, and Tester eventually lost. But “eventually” can mean a couple of terms.
SEN. MIKE CRAPO: TRUMP’S CAFE RESET ENDS BIDEN’S WAR ON GAS-POWERED VEHICLES
The House operates differently. Its two-year terms make the lower chamber of Congress more susceptible to national swings. A majority lost this year could be reclaimed in 2028.
Even so, a good year for Republicans in 2028 would leave much of the damage from this year in place. That is especially true in the Senate, where what looked like a fluke in 2026 may no longer look like one.
Dennis Lennox is a columnist, political commentator, and Republican public affairs consultant. Follow @dennislennox on X.